All things bright and beautiful.
Robert Cargill, on the one hand you condemn Raphael Golb, on the other you correspond with the master of aliases 'Rod of Alexandria'.
http://politicaljesus.com/2010/02/26/qumrancontroversy2/
You wrote: // February 26, 2010 at 10:35 AM
rod,
good post. thanx for the summary. quick question: did jodi really reveal to the class that she was the peer-reviewer on a number of my article submissions and that she rejected each of them?
thanx. -bc
You also wrote: // February 26, 2010 at 10:39 AM
thank you, rod. again, good summary. it’s essentially what she said at my book review session. you’re welcome to chat me offline if you want to discuss further. btw – i’ve added you to my blogroll.
thx again – bc
It's interesting that Jodi Magness rejected all your submissions that she peer-reviewed.
Robert Cargill wrote:
"UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCE DO I DIALOG, BLOG, OR RESPOND TO ANONYMOUS PEOPLES HIDING IN THE SHADOWS, NOT HERE, NOT ANYWHERE. THANK YOU."
Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:XKV8R
Not even 'Rod of Alexandria'?
Robert Cargill wrote:
"But those of us who seek to do justice, love kindness, and walk humbly with our God, will learn to approach the Bible as we do those whom we serve: with patience, forgiveness, empathy, and the kind of service and support that cares for the person, and not for the political position."
Patience, forgiveness, empathy, care for the person! Robert Cargill, does this apply to Raphael Golb?
Hello,nice post thanks for sharing?. I just joined and I am going to catch up by reading for a while. I hope I can join in soon.
ReplyDelete"Let he who is free from sin cast the first stone."
ReplyDeleteHow interesting to learn that such a good disciple of Jesus is teaching William Schniedewind's course on "Jerusalem, the Holy City" at UCLA.
It is also interesting to know that he has teamed-up with a number of individuals to produce a film made by CTVC Ltd, London, called 'Writing the Dead Sea Scrolls', commissioned by the National Geographic channel in the US. This does not yet have a broadcast date.
ReplyDeleteWhile on holiday this week, I read Golb's book Who Wrote the Dead Sea Scrolls (up to and including Chapter 7). It has been quite an eye-opening experience. I am left wondering what such a team, that includes Lawrence Schiffman, Stephen Pfann, and Jodi Magness could add that is very useful. They will no doubt, along with Cargill, finish-up muddying the waters even more than they have done already.